Quick answer
404 errors are not a penalty, and Google expects them, but broken pages with backlinks, traffic or internal links lose value and frustrate visitors. Find 404s in Search Console and a site crawl, then redirect the valuable ones to a relevant page, fix broken internal links and let genuinely gone pages return a 404 or 410.
Last updated: November 2026
Every website has some broken URLs. Products are discontinued, posts are removed, and typos get linked. Google has said clearly that 404 errors do not harm a site’s rankings overall. The real cost comes from the 404s that matter: pages that used to earn links, traffic or leads.
The goal is therefore not zero 404s, but the right response for each one. Some deserve a redirect, some need a link corrected, and some should simply be left alone.
This guide shows how to find 404 errors, decide which to fix, set up redirects correctly and build a custom 404 page that keeps visitors engaged.
In this guide
- What a 404 error is
- Do 404 errors hurt SEO?
- How to find 404 errors
- How to prioritise
- Fixing 404s: redirect, restore or leave
- Repair broken internal links first
- Reclaim lost backlinks
- Create a helpful custom 404 page
- An example from a local business
- Preventing 404s in future
- A quick 404 action plan
- FAQs
What a 404 error is
A 404 status code means the server could not find the requested URL. A related code, 410, means the page is gone permanently. Both tell search engines to remove the URL from the index eventually.
Be careful with “soft 404s”. These occur when a page returns a 200 status but shows an error message or has almost no content. Google treats them as errors, and they waste crawl. A real 404 status is better than a soft 404 for pages that no longer exist.
Do 404 errors hurt SEO?
Not in the sense of a penalty. Google’s guidance is that 404s are a normal part of the web. They matter when internal links lead to them, when external links point at them and the equity is wasted, and when users arrive at them from search results or bookmarks and leave.
A sudden spike after a migration can indicate a problem with redirects. A slow trickle of old URLs is normal. Focus on those with value.
How to find 404 errors
- Google Search Console: check the Pages report for “Not found (404)” and the URLs listed.
- Crawl your site with Screaming Frog, Sitebulb or similar to find broken internal links and their source pages.
- Use a backlink tool to find 404 URLs that still have external links pointing to them.
- Check analytics for landing pages that return 404 and have traffic.
- Review server logs for repeated 404 requests, particularly from search engines.
How to prioritise
Sort 404s by value. Pages with backlinks, impressions or historic traffic come first, because redirecting them preserves something. Pages linked from your own site come next, because fixing the link is quick and improves user experience.
Ignore random junk URLs, such as bot probes for admin files, and old parameter URLs with no value. These are not worth time and will drop out of reports naturally.
Fixing 404s: redirect, restore or leave
- Redirect with a 301 when a similar, relevant page exists. Match topic and intent, not just the section of the site.
- Restore the page if it was removed by mistake and still has value.
- Fix the link at the source if the 404 comes from a typo or outdated internal link.
- Return a 404 or 410 if the content is gone and there is no good replacement.
- Never redirect everything to the homepage, because Google may treat that as a soft 404.
For ecommerce, decide a policy for discontinued products. Redirect to a close alternative or the parent category if it is relevant, and keep out-of-stock pages live if they will return.
Repair broken internal links first
Broken internal links are entirely within your control, and they hurt both users and crawl efficiency. Use a crawl report to see which pages contain links to 404 URLs, then update them to the correct destination or remove them.
This is also a good time to fix links that redirect, replacing them with the final URL. Tidy internal links make your site faster to crawl and easier to use.
Reclaim lost backlinks
When a broken URL has external links, a redirect is usually enough. If the linking site made a typo, you can contact them politely and ask for a correction, or set up a redirect from the misspelled URL to the right page.
Check your backlink tool for 404 targets every few months. Recovering even a handful of strong links can be worth more than a new outreach campaign.
Create a helpful custom 404 page
- Explain clearly that the page was not found, in friendly language.
- Offer a search box and links to your main services, popular pages and contact details.
- Keep your normal navigation, header and footer so visitors can continue.
- Make sure the page returns a real 404 status and not a 200.
- Track 404 hits in analytics to spot recurring broken links.
A good 404 page can rescue a visit that would otherwise be lost, and it costs very little to set up.
An example from a local business
A Leeds dental practice redesigns its site and several treatment pages change URL. Within a month, Search Console shows 40 404 errors. Five of them, such as the old teeth whitening page, have backlinks from local directories and a steady trickle of organic visits.
The practice sets 301 redirects from those five to the new treatment pages, corrects ten internal links that point to old URLs, and lets the remaining random 404s expire. A week later, the whitening page regains its impressions and the broken-link report is clean. The effort took an hour and prevented a slow loss of enquiries.
Preventing 404s in future
- Plan URL changes and set redirects before you publish.
- Avoid changing URLs unless there is a strong reason.
- Run a crawl monthly or quarterly to catch broken links early.
- Check links when you delete or rename content.
- Keep a redirect log and review it every year.
A quick 404 action plan
Export 404 URLs from Search Console and your crawler, then match them against backlinks and traffic. Create a redirect list for the valuable ones, fix the broken internal links, and ensure your 404 page is helpful. Finally, resubmit your sitemap and monitor the Pages report over the next few weeks. If you want help, a website SEO audit will pull this together with a prioritised fix list.
It also helps to agree who owns this task. On many small business sites, nobody is responsible for broken links, so they accumulate until a redesign exposes them. Assign the job to whoever manages your website or your SEO provider, set a monthly reminder, and keep a short record of what you fixed. Over a year this small habit keeps your site clean, protects hard-won links, and ensures visitors rarely hit a dead end when they are ready to enquire.
Technical SEO Services
Crawling, indexing, speed and schema fixed properly.
Frequently asked questions
Should I fix all 404 errors?
No. Focus on those with backlinks, traffic or internal links. Many 404s are harmless and will fall away over time.
Is a 410 better than a 404?
A 410 signals that a page is permanently gone and may be dropped slightly faster, but in practice Google treats both similarly.
Why does Search Console show 404s for URLs that never existed?
Bots and misconfigured links can request random URLs, and old or mistyped links elsewhere can point to non-existent pages. These can usually be ignored.
How long do 404 errors stay in Search Console?
They can remain for weeks or months. Fixing or redirecting them and requesting validation helps clear them faster.